Besides the badness of the writing, my sister Kate
argues that the biggest problem with Pride and Prejudice
fan fiction (commercially published or otherwise) is that it inevitably makes Darcy out to be the stereotypical alpha male of Regency romances. Austen simply wasn't capable of being that obvious, and nothing in the text justifies it. As Kate explains
I personally go along with Phyllis Ferguson Bottomer's argument in So Odd a Mixture that Darcy is borderline autistic. Her delineation of Darcy's character is one of the most accurate and delightful on record. She recognizes what few interpretations do, namely, Darcy is accused of pride in Hertfordshire for reasons that have nothing to do with familial or class pride.
Most versions of Pride and Prejudice focus on Darcy's supposedly prideful thoughts instead of realizing that all of Darcy's problems in Hertfordshire stem from his behavior, not from his beliefs about himself. He is perceived as proud because he won't dance or talk, not because he boasts about his position or even because he gives anyone the "cut direct." He doesn't even cut poor Mr. Collins.
To correct this problem, she has penned A Man of Few Words,
an "addendum" to Pride and Prejudice
that relates Darcy's perspective on the important events in the novel.
A Man of Few Words
can now be purchased together with Mr. B Speaks!
in a revised omnibus edition, The Gentleman and the Rake
. Or separately from the following distributors:
for the perfect Japanese Darcy.)
Labels: criticism, ebooks, kate, kindle, peaks island press, romance